Zack Snyder: A Polarizing Force In Cinema?

Photo Credit: Gage Skidmore

Love him or loathe him, Zack Snyder’s name is one that elicits strong reactions from cinephiles and critics alike. With a career spanning decades, Snyder has become a figurehead in contemporary filmmaking, known for his distinct visual style and penchant for spectacle. However, his work has always been met with a division amongst audiences and critics, with opinions ranging from adoration to outright dismissal.

Zack is back in the news once again as we await the release of Rebel Moon Part Two – The Scargiver. The director actually mentioned in an interview how his films seem to be polarizing after discussing the reviews for Rebel Moon Part One.

“I don’t really have a rebuttal to the reviews. For whatever reason, the reaction to my movies is very polarising, and it always has been, The movie, it doesn’t seem like there’s that much in it that would warrant such visceral responses.”

This also is not the first time the director has mentioned his films being polarizing, back in 2023 Snyder said

“Everyone’s like, You’re a polarizing figure, You know, Love him or hate him … I’m like, Love him or hate him? What did I do? How did I get hate him?”

Let’s delve into the strengths, weaknesses, and the polarizing nature of Snyder’s films.

Criticized Strengths:

Visual Aesthetic: One cannot discuss Zack Snyder without acknowledging his unparalleled visual flair. From the dynamic action sequences to the meticulously crafted frames, Snyder’s films are visually arresting. His ability to create striking imagery often sets him apart from his peers, making his movies a feast for the eyes.

Action Choreography: Snyder has a knack for staging epic action sequences that leave audiences in awe. Whether it’s the slow-motion ballet of combat in ‘300‘ or the explosive superhero showdowns in the DC Extended Universe, Snyder knows how to choreograph action for maximum impact.

World-Building: Snyder has a talent for creating immersive worlds that feel distinct and fully realized. Whether it’s the gritty streets of Gotham City or the ancient battlegrounds of Sparta, Snyder’s films transport viewers to fantastical realms with ease.

Criticized Weaknesses:

Narrative Depth: While Snyder’s films often excel in the visual department, they sometimes fall short when it comes to storytelling. Critics argue that his emphasis on style over substance can result in narratives that feel shallow or convoluted, lacking the depth needed to truly resonate with audiences.

Character Development: Another common critique of Snyder’s work is his handling of characters. While his films may feature iconic figures from comic books or mythology, they often struggle to provide meaningful arcs or character development. As a result, some viewers feel disconnected from the characters on screen.

Pacing Issues: Snyder’s penchant for spectacle can sometimes lead to pacing issues, with films feeling overly long or bogged down by excessive action sequences. This can detract from the overall viewing experience, leaving audiences feeling fatigued rather than exhilarated.

Polarizing Films:

Sucker Punch (2011): This fantasy action film, written and directed by Snyder, follows a young woman who escapes into a surreal dream world to cope with her tragic reality. While visually stunning, the film received mixed reviews for its narrative and thematic execution.

Man of Steel (2013): Snyder’s reboot of the Superman franchise, Man of Steel, explores the origins of the iconic superhero and his struggle to find his place on Earth. The film divided audiences with its darker take on the character but was praised for its visual effects and action sequences.

Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice (2016): Serving as a cornerstone of the DC Extended Universe, Batman v Superman was one of the most polarizing superhero films of its time. While some admired its ambition and epic scale, others found its narrative convoluted and characterizations lacking.

The current Rotten Tomatoes scores for Zack Snyder’s films

1. Dawn of the Dead (2004) – 76%
2. 300 (2006) – 61%
3. Watchmen (2009) – 65%
4. Legend of the Guardians: The Owls of Ga’Hoole (2010) – 52%
5. Sucker Punch (2011) – 22%
6. Man of Steel (2013) – 56%
7. Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice (2016) – 29%
8. Justice League (2017) – 40%
9. Zack Snyder’s Justice League (2021) – 72%
10. Army Of The Dead (2021) – 67%
11. Rebel Moon: Part One – A Child Of Fire (2023) – 21%

In conclusion, Zack Snyder is undeniably a filmmaker who evokes strong reactions. While his films may polarize audiences and critics, there’s no denying his impact on contemporary cinema. Love him or hate him, Snyder’s bold vision and distinctive style ensure that his films will continue to spark discussion for years to come.