‘Bring Her Back’ Review – A Deeply Unsettling Glimpse At Unchecked Grief

Danny and Michael Philippou, the Australian brother duo who captivated horror fans with their directorial debut Talk to Me, prove they aren’t one-trick ponies with their latest release, Bring Her Back. Both films showcase a visual style and aesthetic that are a bit similar, but the latter is more of a psychological slow burn that pays off gradually with each scene of escalating horror. While some horror tropes are present and accounted for, the true horror of the film is human nature itself. What can happen to a person when they are so warped by grief that they lose all concept of right and wrong? This is a story of trauma gone awry, and with this story, the Philippou brothers have crafted something truly haunting and a piece of cinema that audiences won’t be able to easily shake.

The film focuses on Andy (Billy Barratt) and Piper (Sora Wong), a step brother-step sister duo who share a particularly strong bond, but with that bond comes its own share of issues. Andy is wounded by years of physical abuse inflicted by his father, and Piper is a victim of a childhood accident that has rendered her almost completely blind. During a harrowing opening scene, their father dies, which requires a social worker to step in to find them a new foster situation. Initially, the plan is to split them up, but Andy insists that they should stay together until he can legally apply to be her guardian in three months, when he turns 18. Although there is some hesitation due to a violent incident from Andy’s past, they find someone delighted to take them both in when Laura (Sally Hawkins) enters the picture. Laura is more fond of Piper because she lost her daughter, Cathy, in a drowning accident, while she merely tolerates Andy’s presence when they enter her home. Also living with Laura is her nephew Oliver (Jonah Wren Phillips), a mute boy who stares off into the distance and finds himself drawn to the property’s drained pool. It’s not long before it’s obvious that something is wrong with Oliver, and something is also very wrong with Laura.

Bring Her Back features deeply disturbing scenes, and they’ll be enough to make even the most hardcore horror fiends squeamish. The Philippou brothers aren’t afraid to let the camera linger on these moments as they know the audience will be fascinated and disgusted by their presence. One scene involves chomping on the blade of a butcher knife with obvious results, while a table and flesh also become a deeply unnerving snack. The best thing to be said about these scenes is that, despite their grotesque nature, they aren’t gratuitous and are absolutely necessary to sell the depravity of the character in question. These moments serve the story, and that’s something that many horror films can’t say about their display of gore and violence.

What is more frightening than any gore the audience sees is the film’s depiction of grief and how it can be transformed into something very dark and unsettling. Bring Her Back is a downer of a film with very little levity (the early moments with Laura offer up some eccentric laughs), and this makes it a horror film that won’t be for everyone. I left the theater drained by my experience watching it as if I had been punched in the gut, and I mean that as the highest compliment. It achieves its goal of sucking you into its world of despair and it doesn’t let you go. I sat with the film for days, almost if I experienced my own loss, and that’s the power of what these filmmaker brothers have created.

The film is essentially a four-person show, and Sally Hawkins leads the charge with a wonderfully unhinged performance that has many layers. In the beginning, she is offbeat but likable, which is necessary as Laura’s true intentions need to be hidden. Once her true nature begins to emerge, Hawkins is more than dedicated to presenting Laura’s devilish manipulations. However, the true strength of her performance is that she’s able to elicit sympathy from the audience, despite her evil ways. Laura has experienced a profound loss that has lingered with her, and anyone who has lost a loved one will feel her pain. One scene where she shares with Andy how she hasn’t coped with losing her daughter proves to be one of her best due to its quiet but powerful resonance. The fact that she can hit all of these emotional levels without missing a beat is a testament to her talent.

Providing more than capable support are Billy Barratt and Sora Wong, who form a bond that is the heart of the film, which leads to some heartbreaking scenes that shook me to my core. While Hawkins will get a bulk of the praise (and it’s deserved), the film truly wouldn’t work without the relationship developed between Barratt and Wong. Their affection for each other is genuine, and even though it’s shrouded in pain, it’s evident that they will do anything for each other, particularly Andy, as her big brother. A scene in which Andy confesses to a mistake he made as a child that hurt Piper is particularly strong because of the bond forged on screen before this pivotal moment. Lastly, Jonah Wren Philips has to go to some dark places as Oliver and has to do so mostly without saying a word. To say this performance is committed would be an understatement.

It will be interesting to see if mainstream audiences respond to Bring Her Back in the same way they did to Talk To Me. Many horror elements in the film will please genre fans (it’s drenched in atmosphere and its sound design aids in elevating some of the film’s more horrific scenes), but at its heart, this is a deeply disturbing domestic drama about loss, trauma, and grief. To say it’s a downer would be an understatement and there are moments that hit you so hard it’s difficult to not be emersed in its sadness but it’s because of its willingness to go to some dark and honest places that Bring Her Back works, making it one of the best horror films to come along in years.

Bring Her Back is now playing in theaters nationwide courtesy of A24.