Synopsis: THE BEST CHRISTMAS PAGEANT EVER follows six siblings who sneak into church searching for snacks and walk away with the lead roles in the town pageant. Grace (Judy Greer) is directing the performance for the very first time, but she and her daughter Beth (Molly Belle Wright) and husband Bob (Pete Holmes) are in over their heads, especially against a town that wants them to kick the Herdmans out. But the play’s mischievous stars might unwittingly teach a community the true meaning of Christmas.
Don’t let anyone tell you who you are or who you’re supposed to be. As you go through life, people are going to judge and make assumptions about you and your character before you can even speak followed by placing you in a box that makes them comfortable. Whether from rumors, something you or someone who looks like you did in the past, something perpetuated by television, or sometimes nothing at all, ignorance is ignorance. You don’t have to change for anyone, but you can have the glorious satisfaction of proving them wrong. You can stomp on their preconceived notions and remind them that perhaps they should focus their gaze inward. In the end, they’ll be the ones looking foolish.
“I guess, I could try.”
It’s been one heck of a stressful year and with the holiday season upon us, the stress only continues. With that said it would seem that we could all use a feel-good film right about now. With so many holiday favorites to choose from, could a new Christmas classic be on the horizon? Directed by Dallas Jenkins, The Best Christmas Pageant Ever is subtle in faith but strong in compassion. Based on the book of the same name, the film has two objectives, entertain and teach. It sets out to entertain with rambunctious children and its pretentious adults. As the story unfolds, it attempts to teach the true meaning of Christmas while simultaneously focusing on community and acceptance. Furthermore, the lessons are as much for the adults as they are for children, maybe even more so. As we age, pair off, and have kids, we occasionally forget what is truly important.
As someone who isn’t opposed to but doesn’t seek out or frequently watch faith-based films, I appreciate its light-handed touch. It’s definitely Bible-forward, however, it’s done in a delicate matter and shrouded in levity. But is it a Christmas Classic? No. Well, at least not in the context that we’re accustomed to. Having not read the book, I can’t speak to its accuracy, however, I can speak to its holiday execution. Typically, Christmas movies like Elf, The Santa Clause, Jingle All the Way, A Christmas Story, Home Alone, and How the Grinch Stole Christmas immediately come to mind. While all are fun and have wholesome themes and messaging, there’s one glaring difference. Most revolve around Santa and presents in some fashion and that’s where Jenkins’ film sets itself apart.
“It’s all my fault because I didn’t raise my stupid hand.”
With its narration throughout and daily prayers, The Best Christmas Pageant Ever presents like a holy union between A Christmas Story and Are You There God? It’s Me, Margaret. The holiday spirit is alive and well, but standing up for the misunderstood, defenseless, and abandoned supersedes even the most expensive gift. Believe it or not, this is a film for the outcasts. It’s for those who want better for themselves, but no one has ever believed in them. Moreover, it’s for those who don’t judge and see the potential in others.
The film is uplifting and humorous but unfortunately also familiar. It may find itself in unique territory when compared to other holiday movies but rather formulaic next to other faith-driven films. Nevertheless, it successfully delivers a much-needed message. While it may not be an immediate first choice when heading to the theater, it’s a solid choice if you’re looking for something family-friendly. Its rewatchability is low.
Pace & Pop
While its runtime is favorable for a family film and its pace initially feels fine, this film feels longer than it actually is. Whether from a lack of hijinx that it promises or its heavy lean on the sentimental, fun is sacrificed for an important lesson that could’ve been executed another way. It teeters on boring. What popped for me was the portrayal and acknowledgment of the story’s antagonists. However, I couldn’t help but realize, they didn’t apologize in the end.
Characters & Chemistry
Starring: Judy Greer, Pete Holmes, Molly Belle Wright, and Lauren Graham
There aren’t any particular standout performances. Nevertheless, there are emotional moments that are incredibly affecting. While Judy Greer’s portrayal is effective as the caring, thoughtful, and noble, Grace, the character lacks enough depth to make her memorable. Unfortunately, Pete Holmes and his comedy stylings are reduced to a few dad jokes. The eventual draw and reason for staying is to see how the dysfunctional Herdman kids turn it all around. The children are the heart of it all.
The Best Christmas Pageant Ever releases in theaters on November 8, 2024. Stay safe and keep an open mind.
Rated: PG Runtime: 1h 39m Director: Dallas Jenkins Screenplay: Ryan Swanson and Platte F. Clark & Darin McDaniel Based on: The novel by Barbara Robinson Producers: Kevin Downes, Jon Erwin, Andrew Erwin, Darin McDaniel, Chet Thomas, Daryl Lefever Executive Producers: Dallas Jenkins, Jennifer Booth, Tony Young, Christopher Woodrow, K. Blaine Johnston
The Best Christmas Pageant Ever is subtle in faith but strong in compassion. Based on the book of the same name, the film has two objectives, entertain and teach.
-
GVN Rating
Senior Critic. Observing the human race since 1988.
